A Real Estate Broker’s Fiduciary Responsibility to Clients Includes Understanding Delaware Statutory Trust Benefits and Risks

Why we feel it’s important to understand DSTs:

Problem: Rose City Commercial Real Estate sold a client’s  $3,500,000 apartment complex. The property never quite recovered from COVID and she took a loss. But because her acquisition basis was low, she created a $1,100,000 taxable exposure.  The best deal we could find through a standard 1031 like-kind exchange reduced her remaining taxable exposure to $830,000 and would have produced a $35,000 fee for Rose City Commercial Real Estate. We searched for a better option.

Solution 1: Robert Smith and Lynne Smith of Peregrine Equities found a Zero-Coupon DST that covered my client’s replacement property value and debt replacement. I appreciate how they helped my client review and complete the forms and understand the offering. They also had dozens of other offerings, but the deal structure my client chose best fit her requirements. Unfortunately for Rose City CRE, we don’t have securities licenses…so we didn’t earn a $35,000 fee…but we did help a widow with limited resources save hundreds of thousands on her taxes.

Solution 2: DSTs are also a great safety valve if your Second Leg 45-day Identification Deadline is looming. A key characteristic of DSTs is that investors have significantly less control than they would have in a Tenancy-In-Common (TIC) or single ownership deal. But most of my clients are less allergic to giving up control than to paying taxes. PRO TIP: The more time you can give your 1031 Exchange Accommodator and Securities Dealer, the better.

Conclusion: DSTs can provide significant benefits to investment clients. In some cases, they are clearly the best solution for the client; Brokers should suggest them when appropriate.

Notes:

  1. Rose City Commercial Real Estate has provided this information as a starting point to understanding DST Basics. We suggest consultation with CPAs, Attorneys, and other related professionals when appropriate.
  2. Based on the exceptional service we’ve received from our clients, we recommend Equity Advantage (503)635-1031 for 1031 Exchange Accommodation Services and Peregrine Private Capital (503) 241-4949 for assistance with DSTs and other securities.

  3. As you would expect, RCCRE does not solicit nor accept compensation for recommendations.
  4. Only Licensed Security Dealers are permitted by law to sell Securities and accept compensation for doing so.

Frequently Asked Questions

To help Rose City Commercial Real Estate’s clients understand DSTs, I compiled a list of several hundred FAQs. In addition to the Basics below, I have compiled FAQs addressing Exchange Planning, Tax and Records, Investor Fit, Economic Considerations, Due Diligence, etc.

Below are 60 of the Basics:

DST ownership · FAQs 1–10

  1. What is a Delaware Statutory Trust (DST)?A Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) is a legal entity that can hold real estate for beneficial owners. Investors buy interests governed by the trust documents through 1031 Exchange proceeds and/or cash.
  2. Why does DST ownership matter when evaluating a DST?It can replace direct property management with delegated oversight. This makes them a strong option for owners who want to keep growing their wealth with less day-to-day involvement.
  3. What information should I review about DST ownership?The trust agreement defines ownership rights. Part of proper Due Diligence is reviewing and understanding ownership rights and obligations, just as you would with any acquisition.
  4. What is a key risk involving DST ownership?Investors generally lack day-to-day control.
  5. What practical step should I take when evaluating DST ownership?Review the actual trust structure before subscribing.
  6. What comparison helps put DST ownership in perspective?Direct ownership gives you more operating authority and requires vigilance over all aspects of a property and its operation. General Partners of direct ownership assets may have liability exposure to risks exceeding invested capital. This contrasts to DST ownership, which has zero day-to-day responsibilities, limited input into decisions and (typically) no liability beyond invested capital.
  7. What misconception should I avoid about DST ownership?Being formed in Delaware does not establish tax eligibility.
  8. What should I monitor regarding DST ownership?Monitor and retain notices, reporting, and distributions.
  9. What question should I ask my adviser or sponsor about DST ownership?Ask which decisions (if any) investors can actually influence/participate in.
  10. What adverse outcomes should I consider in connection with DST ownership?The underlying property can lose value. Key examples include a key tenant’s financial instability, macroeconomic changes in the economy at large, localized economic changes, etc.

Beneficial interests · FAQs 11–20

  1. What do I own when I buy a DST interest?Your interest represents rights in the trust rather than a separately deeded apartment.
  2. Why do beneficial interests matter when evaluating a DST?Fractional participation can provide access to larger properties and allow investors to diversify their equity across multiple assets (conforming) real estate niches and locations.
  3. What information should I review about beneficial interests?The subscription agreement states your purchased interest.
  4. What is a key risk involving beneficial interests?A percentage interest does not give you a specific rentable space.
  5. What practical step should I take when evaluating beneficial interests?Reconcile your investment amount with the ownership schedule. Remember, this is only one of the steps when performing Due Diligence investigations on DSTs.
  6. What comparison helps put beneficial interests in perspective?A tenancy-in-common interest is a different ownership structure. TICs are similar to DSTs in that the ownership interest is not a divisible piece of the whole. They are different in that TIC owners are typically considered participatory General Partners. In contrast, DST members are typically are nonparticipating partners.
  7. What misconception should I avoid about beneficial interests?Fractional ownership does not itself create diversification. But you can achieve diversification by investing in multiple offerings.
  8. What should I monitor regarding beneficial interests?Track changes to your recorded ownership.
  9. What question should I ask my adviser or sponsor about beneficial interests?Ask how economic interests and voting rights differ.
  10. What adverse outcome should I consider in connection with beneficial interests?Selling your interest will likely require consent of both the DST Sponsor and a qualified (accredited) buyer.

The DST sponsor · FAQs 21–30

  1. What does a DST sponsor do?The sponsor organizes the offering and arranges its business structure.
  2. Why does the DST sponsor matter when evaluating a DST?Its execution affects acquisition, operations, reporting, and disposition. Evaluating the sponsor is a significant component of proper Due Diligence.
  3. What information should I review about the DST sponsor?Review sponsor biographies, financial disclosures, and litigation history.
  4. What is a key risk involving the DST sponsor?A polished marketing presentation can hide weak execution; The dollars are in the details.
  5. What practical step should I take when evaluating the DST sponsor?Examine realized results across multiple market cycles.
  6. What comparison helps put the DST sponsor in perspective?A property manager performs a narrower operating role.
  7. What misconception should I avoid about the DST sponsor?A familiar sponsor name is helpful but does not guarantee performance.
  8. What should I monitor regarding the DST sponsor?Track personnel departures and financial problems.
  9. What question should I ask my adviser or sponsor about the DST sponsor?Ask who remains responsible after fundraising ends.
  10. What adverse outcome should I consider in connection with the DST sponsor?Sponsor distress can disrupt administration even when properties operate.

Passive ownership · FAQs 31–40

  1. How passive is owning a real-estate DST?Passive ownership delegates property decisions and daily management.
  2. Why does passive ownership matter when evaluating a DST?It may reduce/eliminate the owner’s management workload and participation.
  3. What information should I review about passive ownership?Management agreements explain who performs the work. Pay particular attention to the Operating agreement.
  4. What is a key risk involving passive ownership?Delegation creates dependence on other parties.
  5. What practical step should I take when evaluating passive ownership?Decide how much control you can comfortably surrender.
  6. What comparison helps put passive ownership in perspective?A third-party manager on your own building gives you more control. DSTs are on the opposite end of the spectrum.
  7. What misconception should I avoid about passive ownership?Passive does not mean risk-free or oversight-free.
  8. What should I monitor regarding passive ownership?Read and save periodic reports even when income arrives regularly.
  9. What question should I ask my adviser or sponsor about passive ownership?Ask who handles major operating emergencies.
  10. What adverse outcome should I consider in connection with passive ownership?You may be unable to intervene directly.

Cash purchases · FAQs 41–50

  1. Can I buy a DST without doing a 1031 exchange?An investor can buy eligible DST interests using non-exchange cash.
  2. Why do cash purchases matter when evaluating a DST?This permits investment without selling another property first.
  3. What information should I review about cash purchases?Subscription documents establish purchase requirements.
  4. What is a key risk involving cash purchases?Investment risks remain even without exchange deadlines.
  5. What practical step should I take when evaluating cash purchases?Evaluate the investment independently of tax deferral.
  6. What comparison helps put cash purchases in perspective?A 1031 purchase adds exchange-specific requirements.
  7. What misconception should I avoid about cash purchases?Cash investment does not retroactively shelter an earlier taxable sale.
  8. What should I monitor regarding cash purchases?Track purchase basis and closing records.
  9. What question should I ask my adviser or sponsor about cash purchases?Ask how cash investors are treated economically.
  10. What adverse outcome should I consider in connection with cash purchases?Your money may remain illiquid for an uncertain period.

Investment minimums · FAQs 51–60

  1. What is the minimum investment in a DST?Minimum subscriptions are set by each offering.
  2. Why do investment minimums matter when evaluating a DST?They influence how broadly you can allocate available equity.
  3. What information should I review about investment minimums?The offering documents state the minimum and permitted increments.
  4. What is a key risk involving investment minimums?A minimum may be too large for prudent portfolio sizing.
  5. What practical step should I take when evaluating investment minimums?Check the minimum before reserving an allocation.
  6. What comparison helps put investment minimums in perspective?Direct property purchases often much require larger absolute capital commitments.
  7. What misconception should I avoid about investment minimums?There is no universal minimum for all DST investments.
  8. What should I monitor regarding investment minimums?Monitor remaining offering capacity before funding.
  9. What question should I ask my adviser or sponsor about investment minimums?Ask whether exchange and cash minimums differ.
  10. What adverse outcome should I consider in connection with investment minimums?Small subscriptions can still incur substantial embedded costs that lower yields.

Source Materials

Some of the resources searched while compiling these FAQs include:

  • R1 · DST tax structure: IRS Revenue Ruling 2004-86. Read the ruling’s factual limits; it does not establish that every DST qualifies.
  • R2 · Federal exchange requirements and reporting: IRS Instructions for Form 8824 and IRS Publication 544. Check the applicable tax-year versions.
  • R3 · Section 1031 statute: 26 U.S.C. § 1031. Transaction-specific interpretation requires professional review.
  • R4 · Private-placement risks: SEC Investor.gov private-placement bulletin. Relevant topics include illiquidity, potential loss, and limited disclosure.
  • R5 · Investor eligibility: SEC accredited-investor guide. Eligibility and investment suitability are separate questions.
  • R6 · Oregon exchange tracking: Oregon Form OR-24 instructions and Oregon current forms index. Confirm the current form and its application to your transaction.
  • R7 · Partnership contribution rule: 26 U.S.C. § 721. A partnership contribution is different from a section 1031 exchange.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top